Semi-Final 5 Recap30 May 09

littlegrass30/05/2009 19:07:37

dont beliver why some of British are so mean to a 10 years old girl? it may show some degress of jealous. really repersented some British!

lexi2430/05/2009 16:58:13

I can`t believe these mean comments..Shes 10 and was very nervous..she wasn`t kicking and screaming to get her own way..the judges were right to put her through and as for Greg he didn`t do very well on the night either.

school miss30/05/2009 16:33:15

I am appalled at the flagrant disregard for equal opportunities and discriminatory precedents displayed on 29/05/09.It is nerve racking for anyone on stage, there should be no differentiation between competitors. You taught children, kicking off, stamping feet and make a scene will get your own way. As a parent working daily with children, behaviour management relies on rules/consequences. Managing disappointment is a crucial life skill.

canadiancaregiver30/05/2009 15:29:27

Conniving choirgirl is a better description. Not brave. Certainly Not an opera singer ! That makes me laugh.

sammieee4530/05/2009 14:48:07

I totally agree. This is not fair at all. I just heard Piers' view on how Simon was right with what he said and how it was a one of. A one off should not be allowed! Greg should have not been pushed out but should have had the place too if anything. How anyone can say crying on stage is brave, I don't know. If she HAD to have the second chance then I agree with a comment posted on another area of this site. She should have done it after the phone lines closed, so its slightly more fair.

rozina430/05/2009 13:47:20

Let's tell them what we think - sign at http://www.petitionspot.com/petitions/noholliesteel/

122artina30/05/2009 13:07:40

I agree, she is not brave! She is just spoilt. And it was confirmed to her tonight that tears will get you what you want! It obviously works with her parents and it worked with the judges as well! Well done judges! What is going to grow up from this child?

jaegus30/05/2009 12:37:49

Brave???? Surely you cannot be aluding to Hollie Steele? There is nothing brave about a 10 year old having a tantrum on stage. The hundreds of thousands of 10 year olds battling war/illness/famine/drought are brave, she is NOT.